America’s Bee Crisis: Part 3 – Native Bees Get It Done!

This is Part 3 of an ongoing series about the state of bees in America. Prior posts are:
Part 1 – How Did We Get Here?
Part 2 – Our Big, BEE-utiful World


Generalist Species: ones which thrive in a broad range of habitats or on a wide variety of foods.
Specialist Species: those which can survive in only a limited geographic area, or on a narrow range of foods.

That seems pretty clear. Humans are generalists whose range encompasses pretty much all of Earth and we eat just about everything. Pandas are specialists who survive solely on the bamboo that grows in the forests of China. Our adaptability has led to our success, while the panda’s immutability may lead to its demise. But consider this: If much of the food we grow is pollinated by a single species of insect, are we truly generalists? In a way, we have specialized our system of food production by relying so heavily on the European honeybee. Thus, we have exposed ourselves to the risks that other specialist species face – we have made our diet precarious. But we can still generalize crop pollination by including our native bees, and the benefits of doing so will reach far beyond making our food supply more secure. In fact, native bees can help us produce more abundant and nutritious crops. How? Because they interact with flowers differently from honeybees.

America’s Bee Crisis: Part 3 – Native Bees Get It Done!

SweatBee2

Nature’s Grand Puzzle
Everywhere on Earth we find evidence of coevolution, or species that have evolved together and interact in a unique way. They are more successful together than they would be apart, and sometimes depend on each other for their survival. Bees and flowers are two such species, yet this simple explanation belies their complex relationship. For just as there is a kaleidoscope of flowers on the Earth, so there is of bees.

All bees share the same basic anatomy, but they differ in ways that are important to pollination: size, furriness, type of pollen-collecting hairs, and tongue length. A very small flower will need a tiny bee to explore it’s recesses. Temperate plants need bees that are adapted to cold weather. A wide, flat flower, like a daisy, offers its nectar freely to any visitor, but a deep, bell-shaped flower needs a bee with a long tongue. In this way bees and flowers are like puzzle pieces; some fit together and others don’t. When a flower and a bee aren’t a good fit, incomplete pollination is the result.

Bee with tongue extended by Roger Sanderson.

Bee with tongue extended by Roger Sanderson.

For many years our ignorance (or perhaps our arrogance) led us to believe that any bee could pollinate any flower, and that honeybees, being so easy to domesticate, were the best choice for crop pollination. But though it may be possible to force two puzzle pieces together without them being a perfect fit, you will never be able to complete the puzzle. In this way, we have been trying to use honeybees as a sort of universal puzzle piece, and it’s not working as well as we’d hoped. There truly isn’t one bee that suits all the flowers of the world, and this includes the flowers that become our food.

The Honeybee
Honeybees are industrious insects, and extremely efficient at the work that they do. Of the many thousands of workers in a hive, each and every one has a unique job to do; some tend the Queen; others care for the larvae; a few will be sentinels, guarding the hive; but many more are foragers. Foragers bring back nectar to make honey, and pollen to feed their young. Foragers can be very specialized in their jobs, so that one bee may collect only pollen, while another collects only nectar. A bee gathering only pollen or only nectar will not visit all parts of the flower to achieve pollination.

Honeybees have a tongue of moderate length – it is neither short nor long. This allows them to visit a wide variety of flowers, but it also prevents them from nectaring from deep flowers. However, bees are clever! They have learned to chew a hole at the base of a flower to access the nectar, bypassing the flower’s reproductive parts. This is called “nectar-robbing” because the bee gets the nectar without pollinating the flower.

Honeybee stealing nectar.

Honeybee stealing nectar from Lobelia laxiflora.

Like all bees, honeybees have six legs. On their hindmost legs are corbiculae, or pollen baskets, for carrying pollen. Honeybees are very good at tightly packing their baskets with moistened pollen so that little falls out in flight or while stopping at flowers. It’s fun to plant a variety of flowers in the garden and watch the honeybees fill up their baskets with different colored pollen! However, since the pollen is so well-secured in their baskets they mainly aid in pollination by the hairs on their bodies, which small amounts of pollen cling to and fall off of eventually.

The Bumblebee
Everyone’s favorite bee! Our fuzzy friends the bumblebees are so much fun to watch buzzing around the garden. But all that fuzz serves a useful purpose: it insulates the bumblebee, enabling her to fly and visit flowers in damp weather. Because she wears a fur coat and hibernates underground, the bumblebee is well suited to areas with severe winters. Bumblebees can also raise their body temperature by vibrating their wings, allowing them to fly when morning temperatures are cold. A bumblebee’s fur also serves the happy function of becoming electrostatically charged while she is flying; when the bee then lands on a flower her charged fur is like a magnet picking up pollen and carrying it to the next flower. With all that fur she’s just kind of a messy bee. She’s got pollen all over and it brushes off everywhere she lands.

Bumblebee covered in pollen by

Bumblebee covered in pollen by Peter Nijenhuis.

There are more than 50 species of bumblebees in the U.S., and they have tongues of varying lengths, but overall the bumblebee is a long-tongued species. They excel at pollinating flowers which are deep and narrow. Additionally, bumblebees show a predilection for these complex flowers.

Bumblebees are also masters of buzz-pollination. This is a really neat trick! You see, some flowers don’t give up their pollen so easily, and may even have an opening that many bees can’t fit in. No problem for the bumblebee! She can grab onto a flower and vibrate her body to shake that pollen out. It sticks to her fur and she gathers it up to pack in her pollen baskets. While she is shaking the pollen out, she is also distributing it within the flower, achieving pollination. Some plants that benefit from buzz-pollination are tomatoes and blueberries. There are other native bees who can buzz-pollinate as well, but the honeybee cannot. (Watch a cool video of buzz-pollination here!)

Solitary Bees
While honeybees and bumblebees carry their pollen in baskets, most other bees carry pollen in scopae. Scopae are special coarse hairs that bees can pack pollen into. Each hair is like a branch, and together they form kind of a brushy mass for cramming pollen in. This is a messy job. A messy, messy job. It’s not nearly as neat or efficient as carrying pollen in a basket. These bees are dropping pollen everywhere they go. And that’s a good thing! Bees who carry their pollen in scopae are some of the best pollinators we have because their pollen is falling out all over the place.

Native bee with scopae full of yellow pollen.

Native bee with scopae full of yellow pollen.

Some solitary bees have scopae along their hind legs for carrying pollen. Bees of the megachilid family have scopae on the underside of their abdomens. Just imagine a fat bee belly covered in a thick layer of pollen clinging to some scruffy fur. An orchardist’s dream!

Megachile by Ian Boyd.

Megachile by Ian Boyd. Her belly is loaded with pollen.

Another important point of distinction for the solitary bee is that by working alone to feed her young she interacts with a flower more completely than a honeybee. The solitary bee will always gather both pollen and nectar on her flights, as she needs both to provide a food cache for her offspring. This contrasts with the honeybee, whose job is specialized, and may collect only pollen or only nectar on a foraging trip. The solitary bee, by gathering both, is very thorough on her visit to each flower, spending time at both the top and the bottom, and achieving a high rate of pollination.

Variety is the Spice of Life
This is just a small sample of the thousands of kinds of bees in America. Some are active in the early spring, others in the late summer. Many are generalists, visiting all kinds of flowers; some are specialists, utilizing one particular flower only. Native bees have been largely overlooked in agricultural science for years, so we still have much to learn about their role in crop pollination. However, recent research suggests that we are marginalizing them at our own peril, for the reasons illustrated above and more:

  • “Flower constancy” is the term used to describe a bee’s tendency to fly from flower to flower of the same species. This is crucial to pollination because flowers can only be pollinated with pollen of the same species. You can’t pollinate an apple tree with a plum, for example. Researchers have found that bees are less constant when they don’t face pressure from competing bees, thus lowering pollination rates.
  • Competition for resources from increasing honeybee populations is having a negative impact on native bee populations.
  • Well pollinated flowers – or those that are visited by a variety of bees – produce better quality fruit that has a longer shelf life.

Clearly we are indebted to native bees more than we realize. It is in our best interest to preserve and protect them, and yet through our actions they are struggling. Loss of habitat, lack of food, and exposure to pesticides are taking a heavy toll on our native bee populations. Their needs are not being met by our current industrial agribusiness model. Moreover, our focus on proliferating honeybee populations does not create solutions that benefit native bees.

Long-horned bee on Rudbekia.

Long-horned bee on Rudbekia.

These bees are beautiful. They are a joy to watch in the garden. They are hard working, conscientious mothers, and gentle pacifists. I don’t want to lose them. I hope you don’t want to lose them either. The good news is we don’t have to. We can still walk ourselves back from this precipice we’ve found ourselves on. We can give these bees space to live and food to eat, while also feeding ourselves. We just have to care. And then we have to act.

I hope I’ve given you enough information to make you care.

Learn how to act in Part 4. 🙂

P.S. This is a series of blog posts that will include a giveaway of 2 complete mason bee kits; be sure to follow me here and on Facebook so you won’t miss an installment!

 

The Nitty Gritty
Since acquiring my mason bees in 2008 I have developed a passionate interest in bees in general, and solitary bees in particular. This series is a culmination of my last 6 years spent reading books, scientific studies, and news articles, as well as observing bees in the wild. For further reading on this topic, I suggest:

For information about bee anatomy and bee species: Bees, Wasps, and Ants by Eric Grissell and Bees of the World by Christopher O’Toole and Anthony Raw (out of print).
For information about bee behavior and pollination habits: Attracting Native Pollinators and Pollinator Conservation Handbook (out of print) by The Xerces Society.
For information about bumblebees: Bumble Bees of the Eastern United States and Bumble Bees of the Western United States by Pollinator Partnership (both available as free online PDFs).

You may also like...

6 Responses

  1. Erica says:

    Sarah,
    I have enjoyed reading your series and have found it informative and eye opening. I look forward to hearing about how to taken action. Besides learning how to raise a native bee species, I am interested in learning about the plants bees like (and compliment vegetables). I am especially interested in fall blooming plants as most of my neighborhood seems to focus on spring and summer varieties.

  2. Dave Green says:

    Where do you get the nonsense about honey bees cutting the corollas of flowers to get at the nectar without pollinating them? Honey bees don’t have the mouth parts to do this. The flower slitting is done by NATIVE bumble bees and carpenter bees! Once it is done, honey bees are happy to follow in their train. This kind of error shows up your bias. You cannot make the blanket statement that native bees are better pollinators. Every case is different, and may well vary from one place to another or one season to another. I’ve watched bumble bees (which I love by the way – and I know they are important pollinators) move in a couple minutes to three and even sometimes four different species of plant. In this case, a species-faithful honey bee is a much better pollinator. You also have to take into account that many of our agricultural crops are also imported, and honey bees have been their primary pollinators for eons. I will always try to get a good mix of pollinators; I feed and provide nesting sites and materials for many native bees and wasps – but I’m sure not going to discount the important role of honey bees.

    • Sarah says:

      The photo above of a honeybee stealing nectar from a Lobelia laxiflora flower was taken by me in my own garden. Let me tell you what I observed: the honeybees will alight on the top of the flower and immediately proceed to the back of the flower. There they will sit for an extended time drinking nectar. When I examined the flowers after the honeybees left, I did not find holes in them. Rather, in this case, it appears that the honeybees have figured out how to slip their tongues between the flower petals to access the nectaries. I may have incorrectly assumed that since they are capable of stealing nectar in this way, they are also capable of making holes. I will do some more research on this topic and update this post if necessary. If I am in error, I thank you for pointing that out.

      Now, if there is an error here, is that evidence of bias? No. Rather it is evidence of my lack of scientific training. I am a lay-person; someone outside the academic realm; a concerned citizen, if you will. I believe I have made that clear in the “Nitty Gritty” section on these posts. This is not an exhaustive scientific article. The nectar robbing story serves a useful narrative purpose – it demonstrates that merely pairing one bee with one flower will not necessarily result in pollination. You have to have the right bee for the job.

      I have nothing against the honeybee. I like to eat honey. All bees are a happy sight in my garden, and the more kinds of bees I see the happier I am. However, it would be correct to say that I am a champion of our native bee species. The reason why is because the honeybee does not need my help. It has the substantial resources of the entire worldwide agribusiness industry working on its behalf, due to its critical role in supporting intensive monoculture farming. These industries have, in fact, been so successful at promoting honeybees for agriculture that many people are no longer aware that there is any other kind of bee in the world. These are the folks to whom this series of blog posts is addressed.

      To state that only honeybees are species-faithful is incorrect. All bees demonstrate flower constancy, some to the degree that they visit one kind of flower exclusively. However, constancy can be affected by environmental pressures, such as exposure to pesticides. Lack of competition from competing species of bees also appears to contribute to inconstancy. Another good reason to provide habitat for native bees on your farm.

      RE: utilizing honeybees in your home garden. Please do so! Honeybees are a completely naturalized invasive species. The cat is out of the bag, so to speak. We might as well put them to work pollinating our food. But it is a mistake to assume that if one has honeybees all pollination needs are taken care of. They are not. You mentioned imported crops. Well, take a moment to consider all the “New World” crops we eat: nightshades of all kinds, including tomatoes, peppers, potatoes, and eggplant; winter and summer squashes; blueberries; cacao; sunflowers, etc. These crops, and many more, evolved in an environment where honeybees did not exist. And for many of these foods farmers utilize native bees instead, particularly bumblebees, which are the primary pollinators of greenhouse nightshade crops.

      But let’s take another look at “Old World” crops. Since they come from a region where honeybees are native, does that make the honeybee the best pollinator? Again the answer is not always. For example, scientists have found that just 250 mason bees can pollinate an acre of apple or cherry trees; a job which would require about 2 honeybee hives, or the work of approximately 20,000 bees. Remember that there are approximately 25,000 different species of bees on Earth, of which Apis mellifera is just one, and many of them have unique relationships with particular kinds of flowers. The honeybee is a good general pollinator, but not better than any other bee, and not always the best bee for a particular flower. It is also worth pointing out that Europe and Asia are dealing with similar losses in solitary bees and bumblebees due to increasing monoculture farming, and have also seen lower rates of pollination.

      Honeybees have had the lion’s share of publicity when it comes to pollination and agriculture in this country. Native bees deserve a share of the spotlight. I stand by my statements that utilizing a single insect for crop pollination is not only a dangerous precedent, but one that results in lower crop yields and poorer quality food.

  3. Sharon says:

    May I put a link on my blog to your site? I am trying to learn more about bees and have tried to plant plants for them for years. I try to promote planting native plants for the bees.

  4. John says:

    Thanks for this entry! It seems to cut through the fear-mongering out there by the mainstream media.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers: